Vasumathi
Sriganesh
Director, QMed Services
It was
the year 1980. I was jubilant – having become pregnant after almost three years
of marriage. Like any young girl I was thrilled, but also nursed some doubts and
fears. Till a sister-in-law in the US, sent me a simple book about pregnancy.
It cleared most of my doubts, and definitely all my fears!! After the initial
nausea, I enjoyed every minute of my pregnancy. And later circulated it to all
girls in the family during their pregnancies. Each one of them claimed that it
made a difference. And so did the respective husbands!!
Doctors
have been teaching patients about health and illnesses for years and so have chemists.
While there is nothing to beat the ideal –
“direct education from doctors and nurses”, it is simply not practical to expect
a huge amount of time from these providers today – we are reeling under a terrible
doctor-patient ratio.
Now we have
TV Channels and the Internet that have become additional media for health professionals
to communicate with patients. Books and libraries have been a very major source
of health information in developed countries, but in India books themselves came
in late, and libraries are probably thought of last.
Let
us check out the role of information resources in Information Prescription.
Books,
CDs, pamphlets, videos etc are the best educational tools especially if they are
used in addition to the doctors’ teaching. We may forget some of the doctors’
words as soon as we leave his room and shut the door, but a book or a pamphlet
could be checked repeatedly till we are sure of what we want to know. We can always
ask the doctor, nurse on any healthcare professional, if we have specific doubts.
How can a patient or a health consumer
judge a resource? Check out the following:
1.
The “source” - the author / publisher / organization that has created the
resource. The creator should be someone with a good background – a combination
of being qualified, having a good history, being well known. Most important –
the resource should be authentic.
2.
How recent the publication is - Usually the more recent it is, the better
– exceptions being for historical value items / classical works, and for very
general topics like diets and exercise. Of course, even in these – the resource
should not be very old.
3.
Ease of use: You should be able to find information easily. If it is a
printed resource, there should be a good Table of contents, and an index. If it
is a computer-based resource, then check how easy it is to navigate and how well
the search button works.
4.
Purpose: Does the source intend to teach with “no strings attached”, or
does it intend to promote or endorse some commercial product.
The
above check points are more of a guideline; for example if a company that manufactures
an anti-diabetic drug brings out a book about diabetes, it does not mean that
you need to reject the resource. You only may need to verify certain facts, just
in case there was more focus on promoting the product than on teaching about the
disease.
Having got through these
checklists, it is important “Not to take anything for granted” – in other words
not to blindly accept what you read – the actual content created by an author.
While you need not be overly suspicious of everything that you come across, there
is a process called Critical Appraisal. Broadly this goes as follows:
| | Established | Not
Established |
| Valid | Accept
/ Adopt | May accept, but recognize
that more research may be required |
| Not Valid
| Exercise caution. Look for better
alternatives. Or else decide if it is worth the risk of following advice | DISCARD |
(This
Evidence Grid has been sourced from a presentation by Dr. Arjun Rajagopalan -
Medical Director, Sundaram Medical Foundation, Chennai, with permission)
Any
information that falls in the 2nd and 3rd quadrant, calls for some decision-making
- and it would do well to discuss with your family doctor or doctor friend. Remember
that no medical intervention is 100% fool proof - there is God / Nature / Destiny
to create unexpected situations
Let
us now look at the role of libraries in Information Prescription:
Libraries
that handle health information for lay people may be medical libraries, public
libraries or special consumer health libraries like HELP. In countries like UK
and USA, all three types of libraries handle a consumer health collection and
service. In India, we are still behind, there are very few resource centers, and
HELP is unique.
A library's role
is not just to have a collection of books and related items. The library has to
constantly check and discard any material that is outdated. And also to add new
items, choosing carefully, based on criteria defined above. The library collection
has to be such that people who read or use the resources need not have to worry
about the authenticity (unlike many resources on the Internet).
In
addition to developing a useful collection, the library needs to be a place where
a person knows for sure that he will get all the help possible in finding what
he needs. For this, a good librarian has to ensure that the collection in the
library is professionally catalogued, and is an easy tool for the user to find
information. The librarian needs to know about a whole lot of resources - not
only what is in the library, but those that are on the Internet, and further how
to access those that can be reached for through the Internet (example - other
library resources). Today's librarian has to have a strong technology focus in
providing services, both directly to the client, as well as indirectly while working
with information resources. This is an area that calls for constant update of
professional knowledge.
Apart from
knowing all this, the librarian and the library as a whole has to be really dedicated
to the cause of information prescription / information therapy. The institution
needs to do all it can to welcome users, reach out to users who cannot come over
and exude warmth and caring in providing the services - remember many information
seekers may be in a stressed state of mind - either due to worry or even due to
embarrassment. There is also a real need to market such services and activities
- most people are unaware of the tremendous potential of an excellent library
service. Gone are the days when people think of a library as a "Must visit" venue.
While the Internet is a boon, there
is a flip side too - so much hype has been made about it, making it seem like
the "Instant answer providing machine", that a huge number of people seem to believe
that there is no need for libraries. Nothing can be further from the truth. There
is certainly a call for constantly reorienting library services in Information
Prescribing, but there is an equally major call for all information seekers to
remind themselves - "Reach out to a library". And the library, its services and
most importantly the right information will reach out to you!